,

Tax-Equivalent Yield: The Muni Breakeven Is 24.6%

By

·

·

9–13 minutes

The tax-equivalent yield math turned decisively in favor of munis this week. MUB’s 30-day SEC yield was 3.95% on September 24, 2026, against a 5.24% 10-year Treasury on September 28, per Treasury.gov. That sets the federal breakeven at 24.6%: above it, munis net more; below it, Treasuries do. The Bond Buyer reported muni yields rising another 10 to 15 basis points into quarter-end on September 28, 2026.

Municipal bonds just had a bad month and a good week for buyers. Those two things are the same event.

What follows is the arithmetic that decides whether a tax-exempt fund actually beats a Treasury for you — and the three things the standard formula quietly omits.

What is tax-equivalent yield, and how do you calculate it?

Tax-equivalent yield is the taxable yield you would need to match a tax-free one. The formula is the muni yield divided by one minus your marginal federal rate. It is the only fair way to compare a municipal bond fund with a Treasury, because the two are taxed differently at the federal level.

The formula worked on MUB’s 3.95%

The iShares National Muni Bond ETF (MUB) posted a 30-day SEC yield of 3.95% as of September 24, 2026, per the iShares fund page. That figure is already net of the fund’s 0.05% expense ratio.

Divide 3.95% by (1 − 0.32) for a 32% bracket taxpayer and you get 5.81%. In the 37% bracket it is 6.27%. Add the 3.8% net investment income tax and the top figure becomes 6.67%.

Federal marginal rateTax-equivalent yield on 3.95%vs 7-yr Treasury 5.15%vs 10-yr Treasury 5.24%
22%5.06%Treasury winsTreasury wins
24%5.20%Muni wins narrowlyTreasury wins narrowly
32%5.81%Muni winsMuni wins
35%6.08%Muni winsMuni wins
37%6.27%Muni winsMuni wins
37% + 3.8% NIIT6.67%Muni winsMuni wins
MUB 30-day SEC yield 3.95% as of September 24, 2026 (iShares). Treasury par yields as of September 28, 2026 (Treasury.gov). Federal rates only.

Solve it the other way and you get the breakeven. One minus 3.95 divided by 5.24 is 24.62%. Against the 7-year at 5.15%, the breakeven is 23.30%.

Why did munis sell off into September 28, 2026?

Rates and supply, compounded by quarter-end positioning. The Bond Buyer reported on September 28, 2026 that muni yields rose 10 to 15 basis points while Treasuries firmed by 6 to 7, pushing the 10-year muni-to-Treasury ratio to roughly 80%.

James Pruskowski of Hennion & Walsh told the publication that dealers were “shoring up unsettled positions and balance sheets” and that the market was “trying to make room for a concession in case outflows continue.”

The backdrop is the Federal Reserve. The FOMC raised the target range 25 basis points to 3.75%–4.00% on September 17, 2026 — its first hike since 2023 — and the Treasury curve reflects it. The 10-year moved from 5.17% on September 25 to 5.24% on September 28, 2026.

We covered what that first hike did to bond ETFs across the curve and the duration tradeoff in TLT versus SGOV. Munis are the same mechanics with a tax wrapper bolted on.

What record inflows after a 1.9% loss actually tell you

Money is arriving, not leaving. In the week reported September 23, 2026, VTEB took in $1.7 billion and MUB $1.2 billion — record weekly inflows for both, after municipal bonds had returned roughly −1.9% year to date and 10-year benchmark muni yields hit their highest level since April 2025.

Nathan Will, Vanguard’s head of municipal credit research, said yields had become more attractive relative to taxable bonds.

Here is the skeptical read. The yield that makes the tax math work exists because prices fell, and MUB carries 7.10 years of effective duration as of September 25, 2026. By that duration alone, another 100 basis points of yield would imply roughly a 7.1% price decline — more than 18 months of the fund’s current income. Buyers are being paid for that risk, not spared it.

How much does the bracket change in dollars on $100,000?

Between a $67 disadvantage and a $901 advantage, depending entirely on your rate. Tax-free income of 3.95% on $100,000 is $3,950. A 7-year Treasury at 5.15% pays $5,150 before federal tax. Everything turns on what the IRS takes from the second number.

  1. 22% bracket: $5,150 × 0.78 = $4,017. Treasury wins by $67.
  2. 24% bracket: $5,150 × 0.76 = $3,914. Muni wins by $36 — a coin flip.
  3. 32% bracket: $5,150 × 0.68 = $3,502. Muni wins by $448.
  4. 37% bracket: $5,150 × 0.63 = $3,244.50. Muni wins by $705.50.
  5. 37% plus 3.8% NIIT: $5,150 × 0.592 = $3,048.80. Muni wins by $901.20.

The 24% bracket is the hinge. Below it the tax exemption is not worth the credit risk and the wider spread. Above 32% the gap stops being debatable.

MUB vs VTEB: which muni ETF is cheaper to hold?

VTEB, by two basis points. Vanguard’s product page lists a 0.03% expense ratio against MUB’s 0.05%, on $46.3 billion and $45.54 billion of net assets respectively. On $100,000 that is $30 a year versus $50 — a $20 difference that will not decide anything on its own.

MetricMUB (iShares)VTEB (Vanguard)7-yr US Treasury
Expense ratio0.05%0.03%None
Net assets$45.54B (Sep 25, 2026)$46.3B (Sep 28, 2026)n/a
Stated yield3.95% 30-day SEC (Sep 24, 2026)Not disclosed on page checked5.15% par (Sep 28, 2026)
Average yield to maturity4.51% (Sep 25, 2026)n/a5.15%
Effective duration7.10 yrsn/a~6.4 yrs
Holdings7,187 bondsIndex, broad1 security
30-day median spread0.01%n/aInterdealer, minimal
Federal tax on incomeExemptExemptOrdinary income
State tax on incomeMostly taxableMostly taxableExempt
Credit riskMunicipal issuersMunicipal issuersUS government
Annual fee per $100,000$50$30$0
Fund data from iShares and Vanguard product pages; Treasury par yields from Treasury.gov as of September 28, 2026.

Note the last row of costs. A Treasury bought directly has no expense ratio at all — which is exactly why the tax-equivalent comparison, not the fee comparison, is the one that matters here.

What does the tax-equivalent yield formula leave out?

Three things, and all three cut against munis for some investors. The standard formula handles federal income tax and nothing else. State tax, credit risk and duration all sit outside it, and each can flip a close call.

Treasuries are state-tax-free; national muni funds mostly are not

Treasury interest is exempt from state and local income tax. A national fund like MUB holds 7,187 bonds from issuers across the country, so only the slice from your own state is typically exempt where you live.

For a resident of a high-tax state, that reverses part of the federal advantage. The honest version of the breakeven requires your combined rate, and the state treatment of a national fund’s income is not a single number you can look up.

What else the formula ignores:

  • Credit risk. MUB holds municipal issuers; a 7-year Treasury holds the federal government. The yield gap partly pays for that, and tax math does not price it.
  • Duration. At 7.10 years of effective duration, MUB’s price sensitivity dwarfs its annual income. Compare that with the near-zero duration of bills and money market funds.
  • The yield you actually earn. The 30-day SEC yield is backward-looking. MUB’s average yield to maturity was 4.51% on September 25, 2026 — 56 basis points above its SEC yield, because the portfolio reprices faster than the trailing distribution.
  • Inflation. Neither instrument carries a stated breakeven the way TIPS do.

Which investor does each option suit?

Investor profileBetter on after-tax yieldNet on $100,000Why
22% bracket, taxable account7-yr Treasury$4,017 vs $3,950Exemption is worth less than the 120 bp nominal yield gap
24% bracket, taxable accountEffectively tied$3,950 vs $3,914$36 apart; state tax or credit view decides it
32%+ bracket, taxable accountMuni ETF$3,950 vs $3,502Breakeven is 24.6% against the 10-year; you clear it
Top bracket plus NIITMuni ETF$3,950 vs $3,048.80Tax-equivalent yield of 6.67% versus 5.24%
Any bracket, IRA or 401(k)Treasury or taxable bondn/aTax exemption is worthless in a sheltered account
High-state-tax resident, close callRun combined ratesn/aTreasuries are state-exempt; a national muni fund largely is not
Ranked on measurable after-tax income only. Figures use MUB’s 3.95% SEC yield and the 5.15% 7-year and 5.24% 10-year Treasury par yields cited above.

Frequently asked questions about tax-equivalent yield

How do you calculate tax-equivalent yield?

Divide the tax-free yield by one minus your marginal tax rate. A 3.95% muni yield in the 32% bracket is 3.95 ÷ 0.68 = 5.81%.

What is the muni-to-Treasury ratio, and why does it matter?

It is the muni yield as a percentage of the comparable Treasury yield. The Bond Buyer put the 10-year ratio near 80% on September 28, 2026. One minus the ratio is the rough breakeven tax rate — about 20% at that level.

Should munis go in an IRA?

The federal exemption has no value inside a tax-sheltered account, so the entire yield give-up — 120 basis points against the 7-year on September 28, 2026 — is uncompensated there.

Is MUB’s income subject to the alternative minimum tax?

MUB is structured as a national AMT-free municipal fund, which is how it is marketed by iShares. Individual private-activity muni bonds held elsewhere can be AMT-exposed.

Why is MUB’s SEC yield lower than its yield to maturity?

The 30-day SEC yield reflects the last month of distributions net of fees. The average yield to maturity, 4.51% on September 25, 2026, reflects current market pricing. In a rising-rate stretch the second leads the first.

Does the 3.8% net investment income tax apply to muni income?

Tax-exempt municipal interest is generally excluded from net investment income, which is why the top tax-equivalent figure rises to 6.67% once NIIT is layered onto the taxable comparison.

Is a muni ETF or individual muni bonds better?

Different risk shapes. MUB’s 7,187 holdings and 0.01% median bid-ask spread give diversification and daily liquidity; an individual bond gives a known maturity date and no ongoing fee, at the cost of dealer spreads and concentration.

Related: Emerging Markets Bond ETF Fees: EMBX Now 0.65%

Related: T-Bill ETF vs Money Market Fund: 3.84% vs 3.71%

The bottom line

The breakeven is 24.6% against the 10-year Treasury and 23.3% against the 7-year, using MUB’s 3.95% SEC yield as of September 24, 2026 and Treasury par yields as of September 28, 2026. That is the whole answer, and it is not a matter of opinion.

If your federal marginal rate is 32% or higher and the money sits in a taxable account, municipal bond ETFs win on after-tax income by $448 to $901 per $100,000 per year. In the 24% bracket the gap is $36 and the decision belongs to state tax and credit tolerance. At 22% or in any sheltered account, the exemption is not worth buying.

What the tax math does not do is make the duration disappear. The record $2.9 billion that went into VTEB and MUB in the week reported September 23, 2026 bought a better yield and 7.10 years of interest-rate sensitivity in the same transaction.

Both halves of that trade are real. Only one of them shows up in the tax-equivalent yield formula.

This article is journalism, not investment advice. Do your own research before investing.

Sources

Comments

3 responses to “Tax-Equivalent Yield: The Muni Breakeven Is 24.6%”

  1. […] In a taxable account the dividend-heavy payer costs you $17.74 more per $10,000 per year at the 15% qualified rate. Buybacks defer the bill until you sell. Investors who think in after-tax terms already run this math on bond income — the same logic drives the tax-equivalent yield on municipal bonds. […]

  2. […] The last row is the one most comparisons skip. Treasury’s own curve was paying 4.07% at one month and 4.42% at one year on October 7, 2026. A direct bill ladder carries no expense ratio, at the cost of doing the rolling yourself. We ran similar arithmetic on tax drag in our look at the muni tax-equivalent breakeven. […]

  3. […] 4.59% with no state tax, 4.90% at a 5% state rate and 5.19% at 9%. It is the same logic as the tax-equivalent yield on munis, run in […]

Leave a Reply